
Death Penalty – Effective or Immoral?
How many countries in the world use death penalty? Does Capital punishment
really deter crimes and what do different religions say about it?
What do the statics show ? These are common questions and thoughts about
death penalty.
112 countries in the world have now abolished the death penalty in
law or practice and 83 countries still retain and use it, but there
are much less countries which actually execute.
More than three countries a year have abolished the death penalty in
the last decade.
In 2002. 81% of all known executions took place in Iran, China and
the USA.
Against Death Penalty
Although there are a few places in
the Bible you can find support for death penalty, almost every
religious group in the USA looks on executions
as immoral. It is written i The New Testament
that we should not play God and that we should
follow Jesus' example and show mercy.
Studies show that during the 19th century 400
people have been convicted of capital crimes they
did not commit. Of those were 23 people executed.
A wrongful execution cannot be reversed but a
life without parole can. |
 |
Since 1973, 107 prisoners have been released from death row in the
USA after evidence proved their innocence of the crimes they were sentenced
for. The reasons for them being convicted for a crime they did not commit
was prosecutorial or police misconduct; the use of unreliable witness
testimony, physical evidence or confession.
Other prisoners think that death penalty is racist because the statistics
show it. Two-thirds of any case involving a black or Hispanic killing
a white result in the death penalty
A black person is five times more likely to get the death penalty than
a white and those who murdered whites were more likely to get the sentence
than those who murdered blacks.
According to opponents scientific executions have not deterred crimes
more effectually than other punishment.
Family and friends of murder victims go through a horrible time after
the loss but the executions do not help people heal their wounds nor
do their pain. The money that puts on the executions should go to counselling
and other assistance to help the victim's family.
Capital punishment violates the right to life.
For Death Penalty
Christian and Jewish scriptures support Capital punishment
The supporters think that the fear of death penalty may stop others
from committing crimes.
In 1976 there was a pause, where there was forbidden to execute people
and the statistics from that support the death penalty. Other have also
showed an increase of murders during moratoriums.
Even those who are not released but are in prison can murder again.
At least five federal prison- officers have been killed since December
1982. Had these prisoners been executed innocent people would have lived
today.
The Campaign to end the death penalty gives reasons for why the punishment
should be abolished and one of the arguments is “the death penalty
condemns the innocent to die”.
The supporters say that there is absolutely no proof for that statement.
In the USA there is a jury with six members who are selected very carefully.
They have to decide – beyond reasonable doubts – if the
convicted is guilty or not.
So the possibility that a person is being executed for a crime he did
not commit is very small.
And it continues to decrease thanks to the improvement in forensic science.
It is true that death row-prisoners have been released but it's not
proved they were innocent.
Opponents to the death penalty have many organisations and are active
in the media with articles and debates. But the supporters have very
few organisations, they support in silence.
I don't think anyone has the right to take someone else's life even
if the person in question has committed a horrible homicide. If we kill
the murderer we become murderers too!
Instead of killing them we should put them in prison for the rest of
their lives. In that way we can release them if the evidence proves
their innocence.

© 2003 Freeway
Writers: Emma Lindström (sp05-51@park.se)
HTML by: Björn Dahlberg (te04-28@park.se).
|